The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) issued guidance yesterday that drew a line in the sand
against municipal energy financing, a.k.a. Property Assessed Clean
Energy (PACE) programs. These innovative initiatives provide energy
efficiency retrofits for homeowners that are repaid through a property
tax assessment. Since homeowners falling behind on payments must repay
their PACE assessment before their mortgage, giant lenders Fannie Mae
and Freddie Mac will consider participating households in default on
their mortgages for receiving an energy efficiency retrofit via PACE. Their rationale is paper thin.
This is a guest post from the Breakthrough Generation blog. Breakthrough Generation is the young leaders’ initiative of the Breakthrough Institute, a public policy think tank. Founded in 2007, Breakthrough Generation has fostered the development of young thought leaders capable of fully grappling with the scale and complexity of today’s greatest challenges and advancing large-scale solutions over the near and long term. To read more writings from this year’s 2010 Breakthrough Fellows, head to http://breakthroughgen.org
Environmentalists have long couched their opposition to nuclear power in the argument that tinkering with elementary particles to produce energy is inherently unsafe. But advances in climate and nuclear sciences suggest that the dangers posed by today’s nuclear technology are far less serious than the risks of tinkering with global climate systems.
In 1945, J. Robert Oppenheimer gave the go-ahead for the Trinity test, the first human-induced nuclear explosion. As he observed the massive explosion unleashed by his creation, he uttered the now-famous phrase:
“Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds.”
With these words, excerpted from the Bhagavad Gita, Oppenheimer captured and reinforced a widely-held sentiment that nuclear technology is a fundamentally destructive force worthy of great respect and profound trepidation.
This view would be strengthened by the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki a month later and again in 1979 and 1986 by the meltdowns at Three Mile Island and Chernobyl.
Justifiably influenced by the specter of nuclear meltdown or, worse, worldwide nuclear war, early environmentalists adopted a vehement anti-nuclear stance. At the time, nuclear proliferation seemed to present an existential threat to the natural environment, to human health, and to world peace.
Patrick Moore, a founder of Greenpeace, summed it up in his 1976 report Assault on Future Generations:
Nuclear power plants are, next to nuclear warheads themselves, the most dangerous devices that man has ever created. Their construction and proliferation is the most irresponsible, in fact the most criminal act ever to have taken place on this planet.
Forged in an era of fear, uncertainty, and disaster, this uncompromisingly critical stance towards nuclear energy has remained a central tenet of U.S. environmentalism ever since.
While this stance is understandable as a reaction to the events of World War II and Chernobyl, it has become drastically outdated in the nearly twenty five years since the Chernobyl disaster took place. These twenty five years have seen two fundamental, ground-shifting changes.
First, climate scientists–and increasingly the general public–have become aware that carbon dioxide emissions lead to global climate change and a host of resultant ecological and atmospheric consequences. Second, nuclear energy technologies have developed to become far safer and more efficient than their decades-old antecedents.
These two transitions have redefined the energy landscape; taken together, they should redefine the energy debate.
At this point, anyone serious about climate change should be asking themselves: what role should nuclear power have in a clean energy future? Can we decarbonize our economy without nuclear power?
While the science, the technology, and the debate have shifted beneath their feet, mainstream environmental groups have resolutely held their anti-nuclear ground.
The Sierra Club, an early opponent of nuclear power, continues to stick by the nuclear policy it established 36 years ago in 1974:
The Sierra Club opposes the licensing, construction and operation of new nuclear reactors utilizing the fission process.
Greenpeace, another early nuclear opponent, calls not only for no new construction but also for the dismantling of existing plants:
Greenpeace has always fought – and will continue to fight – vigorously against nuclear power because it is an unacceptable risk to the environment and to humanity. The only solution is to halt the expansion of all nuclear power, and for the shutdown of existing plants.
Most recently, Friends of the Earth has been releasing egregious anti-nuclear advertisements employing ominous music, dark photographs, and hyperbolic rhetoric to inspire visceral fear of nuclear power.
Contrary to the frightful narratives sown by mainstream environmental groups, the long-term safety record of nuclear power is in fact far better than that of coal, our primary source of electricity. Even in terms of direct deaths, which do not include the tens of thousands of yearly deaths caused by pollution from coal combustion, nuclear comes out on top:
Compiled by Jesse Jenkins, The Breakthrough Institute
When it comes to waste and emissions, nuclear again emerges the clear winner: while powering a single person’s lifetime with coal produces 68 tons of solid waste and 77 tons of carbon dioxide emissions, a person-lifetime worth of nuclear-generated electricity produces zero emissions and an volume of solid waste the size of a soda can.
These waste and emissions disparities raise a critical question: which is worse, small quantities of radioactive waste in secured storage or huge amounts of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere?
For greens who find themselves increasingly concerned about climate change and its impacts on humans, oceans, and ecosystems, this lesser-of-two-evils debate should not be taken lightly.
Given the capacity of nuclear to produce emissions-free energy with orders of magnitude less waste than coal combustion, it would appear that the environmental community’s reflexive rejection of nuclear energy runs counter to its most basic charge: to employ sound science and smart policy to protect the environment and the people within it.
The BP Oil disaster has brought home one very strong point, we need to change the way we power our lives, from the electricity that runs our homes to the what powers our vehicles we can no longer accept the dangers of an Oil based society.
What the BP disaster may also do is create an [...] Live Stock Trading News | Equities, Forex, Gold, Silver and Oil Trading » News & Events
About three stocks rose for every two that fell on Europe’s benchmark Stoxx Europe 600. Banco Santander SA, Spain’s largest lender, rallied 3.5 percent in Madrid while smaller rival Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria SA climbed 5.6 percent.
Spain’s IBEX 35 Index and Portugal’s PSI-20 increased at least 2.2 percent, the most among western European benchmark [...] Live Stock Trading News | Equities, Forex, Gold, Silver and Oil Trading » News & Events
Spot gold hit a high of ,259.25 an ounce and was bid at ,256.25 an ounce at 1354 GMT, against ,243.40 late on Thursday. U.S. gold futures for August delivery also hit a record ,260.90, and were later up .00 at ,257.70.
Gold rallied to a record high near ,260 an ounce on Friday as momentum [...] Live Stock Trading News | Equities, Forex, Gold, Silver and Oil Trading » News & Events
ASEAN stocks held their gains and many rallied in Friday trading after performing beeter than the rest of the world’s markets this week as regional optimism shielded investors from nagging worries over European debt and mixed global economic data.
ASEAN markets also gained positive fund flows in the week amid strong trade data in May, including [...] Live Stock Trading News | Equities, Forex, Gold, Silver and Oil Trading » News & Events
Europe’s largest bank, HSBC Holdings Plc, sold .4 billion of undated bonds in the biggest issue of its kind for almost two years, re-opening a market that’s been shut since December.
HSBC’s bonds, which have no maturity date and are callable after 5 1/2 years, will pay a coupon of 8 percent, according to a [...] Live Stock Trading News | Equities, Forex, Gold, Silver and Oil Trading » News & Events
Ronn Motor Company (PINKSHEETS: RNNM) announced that the renovation on their new green manufacturing facility and corporate headquarters is nearing completion.
In keeping with their “green” theme, Ronn Motors was able to locate, hire and utilize independent, green, certified, local contractors that have made extensive use of green materials in the construction process wherever possible. [...] Live Stock Trading News | Equities, Forex, Gold, Silver and Oil Trading » News & Events
The MSCI Asia Pacific Index rose 0.2 percent to 116.04 as of 10:55 a.m. in Tokyo. It has gained 3.2 percent this week, on course for its biggest increase since the period ended Dec. 4. South Korea’s won was poised for its biggest weekly jump in 13 months after Finance Minister Yoon Jeung Hyun said [...] Live Stock Trading News | Equities, Forex, Gold, Silver and Oil Trading » News & Events
In May 2010, The Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) Index was rather volatile and closed at 750.43, a 1.71% drop from the previous month due to concerns over Europe’s public debt crisis and domestic political unrest. However, the drop in the SET Index was small compared to regional markets, and was still 2.16% higher than [...] Live Stock Trading News | Equities, Forex, Gold, Silver and Oil Trading » News & Events
Social Media Channels | Follow Us Online